INTERNATIONAL COUNCIL FOR CENTRAL AND EAST EUROPEAN STUDIES
HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
The last year of the twentieth century marked the twenty-fifth anniversary of the creation of an international scholarly association known today as the International Council for Central and East European Studies (ICCEES). It is now into its third decade. When it was founded at the first international and multidisciplinary conference of scholars working in this field, held in Banff, Alberta, Canada, on 4-7 September 1974, it was given the name of International Committee for Soviet and East European Studies (ICSEES). Its creation is best understood as the result of developments in the academic world that were influenced by the state of East-West relations after 1945. Research into and the teaching about the nations and cultures of Russia, later the Soviet Union, East, Central, and South-eastern Europe have always depended on a number of factors that strongly affect the structure and the way the different countries of this area are studied. These include:
- Each country’s position in or proximity to that half of Europe known as Eastern Europe;
- The intensity of their cultural relations;
- The influence of international and domestic politics; and
- Developments in various academic disciplines.
After the Second World War, the global competition between the Soviet Union and the United States exerted a major influence on the establishment of new research centres and academic programmes in the West that specialised in this area. The study of the Communist political system, its society and economy, and East-West relations in particular, received government encouragement and financing. However, when compared with the older established disciplines of language and literature or history, for example, there was little exchange between research centres and scholars around the world. In addition, the conditions for research as well as the ways of thinking and the approaches often differed and, to some degree, still differ from country to country today; this is particularly the case in the United States, Canada, France, Great Britain, Germany, Finland, Israel, Japan, and Australia. On the other hand, the international character of scholarly work per se and the possibilities offered by modern communications made it possible for increased co-operation, or at least the exchange of information, on a hitherto unprecedented scale.
These developments were the main motivation for bringing together the
very different national organisations in the field and for forming a
permanent committee of their representatives, which would serve as an
umbrella organisation as well as a promoter of closer co-operation.
Four national scholarly associations launched ICSEES at the Banff
conference: the American Association for the Advancement of Slavic
Studies (AAASS), the National Association for Soviet and East European
Studies in Great Britain (NASEES), the British Universities Association
of Slavists (BUAS), and the Canadian Association of Slavists (CAS).
Shortly after the Banff conference, the German association (Deutsche
Gesellschaft für Osteuropakunde) joined ICSEES, and by 1980 17
national associations or institutes (in countries where nation-wide
organisations did not exist) had become members of the international
committee. There were additional applications in subsequent years.
Associate membership was instituted in 1990 to include academic
institutions and scholarly organisations from countries where a
national organisation embracing the scholarly community in the field of
Central, East European and Eurasian Studies had not yet emerged. As
ICCEES entered its third decade of existence, the International Council
was composed of 20 full and six associate members.
ICSEES adopted at Banff a “founding declaration” which defined its purpose and aims as follows:
“ICSEES aims to create an international community of scholars and scholarship on Soviet and East European affairs. The advantages of this achievement are manifold: First, the pooling of information breeds ideas. Second, money, time and energy can be saved by joining effort and by reducing duplication over national boundaries, be it in organising conferences or when formulating project designs. Third, in the face of material adversity, it helps to be aware of the international weight the profession carries, and to exchange information on difficulties, which may arise to challenge the profession. Fourth, scholars from countries where Soviet and East European area study is a recent phenomenon deserve a chance to partake of the achievements in methodology, organisation and publication already attained by those who began earlier and who have therefore advanced further. Fifth, young newcomers to the profession should be admitted to the world of international exchange earlier and with greater facility than established procedures would normally allow.”
In his recently published autobiography, Adam Bromke, the spiritus
movens of the Banff conference and first president of
ICSEES,
reminisced about the beginning of ICSEES and the policy of its
presidents to acknowledge excellence and success in the scientific
community but also in international politics (Adam Bromke, Polak w
swiecie, Warszawa, 1995). The latter was necessary because
of the ups
and downs of East-West relations in the 1960s and the early 1970s,
which influenced in a variety of ways the attitude of governments
towards Soviet and East European studies. To this end, after prolonged
discussions, the following resolution was adopted in Banff and served
as a general guideline for ICSEES activities:
“ICSEES will pay special attention to problems connected with the study of the USSR and Eastern Europe as foreign countries: (1) It recognises that scholars of the various member countries exercise freedom of choice as to themes and methods of research and will take into account the particular features of the organisation of research and the methods of international co-operation existing in these countries. (2) In order to ensure better mutual exchange of information between specialists on the USSR and the nations of Eastern Europe and scholars from the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe in the various disciplines, ICSEES will seek to develop the broadest possible co-operation on all problems of common interest through exchange of documents, discussions on methodology, organisation of joint meetings, exchange of scholars and all other appropriate forms of collaboration.”
In the wake of this resolution, ICSEES sought to include scholars from
East, Central, and South-eastern Europe as well as the Soviet Union in
its activities, which meant inviting them to participate in its world
congresses. 820 officially registered delegates and some 500 observers
had attended the Conference in Banff. Participants had come from 29
countries, including 11 representatives from the USSR and 14 scholars
from Eastern Europe. The opening speech, a balanced view of culture and
science under the conditions of ideological controversy, was given by
Jan Szczepanski, President of the Polish Academy of Sciences.
Unfortunately, he could not deliver it in person. Jerzy Wiatr, who
became Minister of National Education in Poland in 1996-97, read it for
him. ICSEES demonstrated in this way its policy of championing academic
freedom under difficult political circumstances.
The interdependence of politics and scholarly interests in this area
was particularly evident in the preparations for the Second World
Congress, which was organised by the Deutsche Gesellschaft für
Osteuropakunde in close cooperation with ICSEES. It was held in
Garmisch-Partenkirchen, Bavaria, on 30 September - 4 October 1980. The
programme committee extended invitations to individual scholars in
different disciplines in all of the countries of the Soviet bloc as
early as 1978 and ensured that the Academy of Sciences in each country
was informed about the procedure concerning congress preparations,
asking for their support and participation. The initial response from
most of them seemed positive. In the spring of 1980, the Soviet Academy
of Sciences sent a small delegation to Germany for further
consultation. As a result of open discussions, there was some hope that
Soviet scholars would participate, but in August the organising
committee received an official refusal by telegram. Shortly thereafter,
this refusal was followed by similar cancellations from the other
countries. Their Communist governments had decided to boycott the
Garmisch-Partenkirchen Congress; still 18 scholars from Yugoslavia,
Poland, China, Romania, and Hungary, who ignored this boycott, were
among the 1415 registered participants from 32 countries who took an
active part in the congress.
The Third Congress, which took place in Washington, DC, on 30 October -
4 November 1985, also had only unofficial representatives from the
East. There were 3095 registered participants from 41 countries among
whom were 45 Soviet and East European scholars who participated in a
multitude of panels. In the wake of the Washington congress, the
International Committee was renamed International Council in 1988.
Nevertheless, the Soviet attitude towards ICSEES, as well as that of
other Communist governments, remained until 1989. In the German
Democratic Republic, for instance, there were even insinuations of an
international “conspiracy” against the socialist
countries. The role assigned to ICSEES by Communist propaganda was
without foundation, but of practical importance. Change, however, was
on the way.
The 1990 congress was marked by the political transformations that were
taking place in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union. It opened the way
for the composition and the activities of the present International
Council for Central and East European Studies (ICCEES). Held in
Harrogate, England, on 21-26 July 1990, the IV World Congress saw the
participation of about 240 scholars from nearly every country in
Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union out of some 2,400 participants. It
heralded a break with the past and underlined their hope for the
future. The papers, discussions, and the proceedings published
afterwards marked an historical event in the history of ICSEES and
especially in the studies of this area. Former political and
ideological barriers no longer stood in the way and the ground was laid
for common scholarly research. The change of name from ICSEES to
ICCEES, adopted in 1993, may therefore be seen as the fulfillment of
one of the original aims of the organization referred to above:
“to seek to
develop the broadest possible co-operation on all
problems of common interest through exchange of documents, discussions
on methodology, organization of joint meetings, exchange of scholars
and all other appropriate forms of collaboration.”
The V World Congress was held in Warsaw on 6-11 August 1995. Some 1400
scholars found their way to the Polish capital. The location clearly
demonstrated what was only too obvious to all congress participants,
namely that the former distinctions between the scholarly communities
of East and West had completely disappeared. ICCEES had become an
organisation in which scholars from all parts of the world were active
on equal terms.
It is the Finnish city of Tampere, not unimportant in the history of
communism (it is here that Lenin and Stalin first met), which hosted
the VI World Congress from 29 July to 3 August 2000. The choice of
Finland was appropriate for another reason: the twenty-fifth
anniversary on 1 August of the first Conference on Security and
Cooperation in Europe (CSCE) that had been held in 1975 in Helsinki.
Some 2000 participants from 48 countries attended the congress in the
Tampere Hall Congress centre and the adjacent University of Tampere
campus. It was a remarkable congress for a number of reasons: the
anniversary of the creation of the CSCE was celebrated at the congress;
for the first time since the creation of ICCEES, the second largest
delegation was the Russian one; the congress programme included three
concerts (one that was broadcast to the European Union), several film
presentations, a commercial exhibit of literature and information
services; and post-congress tours were organized not only to Lapland
and eastern Finland, but also to Estonia and St. Petersburg in Russia.
The VII World Congress was held in Berlin, Germany from 25 to 30 July
2005 at the Humboldt-Universität in former East Berlin and was
organized by the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Osteuropakunde
(DGO) under the direction of Professor Thomas Bremer of the
Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität in
Münster. The theme of the congress was: “Europe, a
common home” There were 1,792 registered participants from 49
countries when the congress was opened at the Haus der Kulturen der
Welt by Polish President Aleksander Kwaśniewski, the President of the
DGO, Member and former Speaker of the German Bundestag, Prof. Dr. Rita
Süssmuth, and other German dignitaries. There were 1,300
papers given in 18 different areas of research. This time, the second
largest delegation, after the German one, was from the United States,
followed by that of the Russian Federation.
The VIII World Congress will be held in Stockholm, Sweden in 2010, and
will be organized by the Swedish Society for the Study of Russia,
Eastern and Central Europe and Central Asia. The theme of this congress
will be: “Eurasia: prospects for wider
cooperation.” Information about the congress will be made
available in time in the pages of the International Newsletter.
THE INTERNATIONAL COUNCIL
ICCEES (full council) is composed of representatives of national
organisations and associated institutions. In view of the diverse
nature of Central and East European studies world-wide and of the
varying types of national organisations, four countries have two
representatives (UK, Canada, Germany, and USA) while the others have
one. Countries with an associate membership may be represented by an
observer at the meetings of the International Council. The term of
office is normally five years and the International Council meets at
each congress and once in the intervening period.
The work of the council is carried out by an Executive Committee, which is responsible for preparing the agenda of meetings of the International Council and calling otherwise pertinent matters to its attention. The Executive Committee consists of a President, two Vice Presidents, a Secretary, five members, and, ex officio, the Director of the International Information Centre. Term of office is the same as for the full Council. The Executive Committee normally meets annually.
The first Executive Committee was composed, among others, of some of
the organizers of the Banff Conference, namely Professor Adam Bromke of
McMaster University, Canada, who became the first ICCEES President and
Professor Don K. Rowney of Bowling Green State University, USA, who
became Secretary. At the Second World Congress in 1980, Professor Oskar
Anweiler of the Ruhr Universität Bochum, Federal Republic of
Germany, became the second ICCEES President with Professor Stanislav J.
Kirschbaum of York University, Glendon College, Canada, as Secretary.
In 1985, Professor Alexander Dallin of Stanford University, USA, became
President and was succeeded by John D. Morison, Esq., of the University
of Leeds, United Kingdom, as fourth ICCEES President in 1990. In 1995,
in Warsaw, Poland, Professor Ferdinand Feldbrugge of Rijksuniversiteit
te Leiden, Holland, was elected fifth ICCEES President. The sixth
president, elected at the Tampere congress in Finland in 2000, was
Leslie T. Holmes of the University of Melbourne, Australia. His
successor, elected in Berlin, Germany in July 2005 is Emeritus
Professor John D. Elsworth of the University of Manchester, United
Kingdom.
In its constituent period, the International Council and its Executive
Committee concentrated on the basic questions of organization, finance
and exchange of information through the International Information
Center and its International
Newsletter. While continuing its indirect
contribution to international activities in this way, ICCEES has also
sought to devote time and energy to special programmes and regional as
well as binational initiatives in the field. In recent years, the
development of links and projects with scholars in ex-Communist
countries has become an activity of particular importance.
THE INTERNATIONAL INFORMATION CENTRE
One of the earliest decisions of the Executive Committee was to
establish an organ of international communication. To this end an
International Information Centre was established at the University of
Glasgow, Scotland, in 1975 to document and stimulate international
communication. In 1979, the Centre was transferred to the Institut
national d'études slaves in Paris, France. In 1988, the
Centre moved from Paris to Uppsala University in Sweden. As a result of
the development of electronic communication, the Centre was also given
a mission in 1993 to link into the development of electronic
transmission of information, and was transferred to the University of
Melbourne, Australia, to take effect in 1995. At the same time, a
European Information Centre was set up at the Finnish Institute for
Russian and East European Studies in Helsinki, Finland with the task of
establishing a data base of scholars and institutions active in the
field within the countries of Central Europe and the former Soviet
Union. In 2000, the Centre was moved to the Finnish Institute for
Russian and East European Studies in Helsinki, thus bringing together
under one roof all of the communication activities of ICCEES.
The International Information Centre publishes an International
Newsletter twice a year. It is distributed to all
individual members
through their national associations and committees free of charge. The
International Newsletter
circulates in 7,000 copies world-wide and 44
issues had been published by the time ICCEES was celebrating its
twenty-fifth anniversary. All issues since January 1996 (No. 36) are
now available on the web page of the Finnish Institute for Russian and
East European Studies in Helsinki (www.rusin.fi). On 1 October 2005,
the ICCEES Information Centre moved from Helsinki, Finland to
Münster, Germany. All important information on ICCEES and all
issues of the International
Newsletter after September 2005 (No. 56)
are available on the website www.iccees.org.
The International
Newsletter is the facet of ICCEES activity, which the
individual scholar can see most readily. It is also a more regular
vehicle of communication than chance meetings with colleagues at
conferences. News is collected by direct correspondence and travel and
from the many bulletins, which exist all over the world. All those
working in the field are invited to write to the Editor about relevant
institutional activities.
Another important facet of ICCEES activity is the publication of
congress proceedings. After each world congress, participants are
invited to submit their papers to a panel of volume editors selected by
a General Editor named by the International Council. The list of
volumes from each congress is published below. From the Berlin congress
there will be volumes that will be part of a new ICCEES series entitled
Studies in Central and
Eastern Europe published by Palgrave Macmillan.
FINANCE
The activities of the International Council have been supported by a
number of generous grants from governments, institutions, and
universities. The foreign ministries of Canada, France, the Federal
Republic of Germany, Israel, Japan, the United Kingdom, and the United
States of America have provided financial support, as have the Canada
Council, the Hokkaido Municipal Government, the Nippon Steel
Corporation of Japan, the Social Sciences and Humanities Research
Council of Canada, and the Finnish Institute of Russian and East
European Studies. In addition, a number of national associations have
been providing annual contributions to ICCEES. The universities to
which the officers of ICCEES have been and are currently attached have
also rendered valuable assistance, none more so than Bowling Green
State University (U.S.A.), the University of Glasgow (U.K), I'lnstitut
du monde soviétique et de l'Europe centrale et orientale
(France), l'Institut national d'études slaves (France),
McMaster University (Canada), Ruhr Universität Bochum
(F.R.G.), Stanford University (U.S.A.), Uppsala universitet (Sweden),
York University (Canada), the University of Leeds (U.K.),
Rijksuniversiteit te Leiden, (Holland), the University of Manchester
(U.K.), and the University of Melbourne (Australia).
The International Information Centre and the International Newsletter
have also received financial support directly from a number of
agencies. Initially established thanks to a grant from the Ford
Foundation, the Centre has benefited from the assistance provided by
the Volkswagenwerk Stiftung (F.R.G.), the French Ministry of External
Relations, the Bank of Sweden Tercentenary Foundation, and the Sasakawa
Peace Foundation of Japan. There have also been ad hoc
contributions
from various sources for the World Congresses held under the auspices
of the International Council and for meetings and the travel of ICCEES
officers. From among many sponsors of the Tampere congress, for
example, the European Union made a generous contribution through its
Phare and Tacis Programmes.
FUTURE PERSPECTIVES
It is now a little over three decades ago since the need was felt by
scholars to coordinate the efforts in the “free
world” to describe and analyze the Communist political
system, its society and economy, and East-West relations in particular.
Half-way through this period, the Communist system collapsed, the
region that was the object of study was reorganized, and many of the
nations as well as the new states that emerged set out on a path of
democratic development, economic growth, and, in many cases, inclusion
in Western institutions. The process turned out to be complex, and
there were setbacks. Yet, by 2004, the European Union as well as the
North Atlantic Treaty Organization had welcomed those post-Communist
states that had met all of the requirements for membership. Not all of
the applicant states achieved this objective; but the process is
ongoing. For this reason, perhaps even more than before, the region
that encompassed the former Communist world demands study, explanation,
and analysis, as both centripetal and centrifugal forces are at work in
each state and across the region.
The theme of the 2005 Berlin Congress - “Europe, a common home” - well exemplified the challenges and the tasks that have awaited the academic community throughout the world since the fall of communism. Ideological barriers no longer separate academics, researchers, and scholars. But new objectives have appeared; scholars in Europe well know what role they can play in the process that has been bringing about European unification; those looking in from the outside can offer different perspectives, other approaches. This is what the Tampere Congress heralded. And this is what the Berlin Congress challenged all scholars around the world and in particular the International Council for Central and East European Studies to do in the years to come. In anticipation that these changes will continue to take place and will embrace additional countries and peoples east of Europe, the Swedish congress offers the theme: “Eurasia: prospects for wider cooperation.”
What better perspectives for greater scholarly cooperation and
coordination could there be - the very vision of the
“founding declaration” that was adopted at the
first congress in Banff in 1974. The past three decades may well have
been merely a prologue.
Stanislav J. Kirschbaum
Secretary, ICCEES